I’m the kind of devout physical media advocate who’s even willing to buy DVDs, Blu-rays, and 4K discs of movies I haven’t seen before. By applying the same logic that I would apply when seeing a new movie in the theater for the first time, I can decide whether a film I’ve yet to watch is worth buying on disc. Most of the time, I avoid buyer’s remorse.
That said, some physical media collectors take this idea to the next level. They may buy movies that they never end up watching. Or, if they do end up watching them, it may be months or even years after they first bought that particular disc.
It would be impossible to cover all the reasons some cinephiles may engage in a behavior that to outsiders can seem wasteful. It’s also worth noting that in some instances, it actually is, well, wasteful.
Growing a physical media collection can be a very rewarding experience. Still, you should also always keep in mind practical factors like your budget when buying movies and shows in physical formats.
Nevertheless, there are some potentially valid psychological explanations for buying a DVD, Blu-ray, or 4K disc of a movie you haven’t seen yet and don’t necessarily plan on watching in the near future. Whether any of these explanations are convincing enough to cause you to do the same will vary on a case-by-case basis. It’s simply worth exploring this aspect of physical media collecting to get a better sense of the motivations many physical media collectors may have for making certain purchases.
Sometimes you’re just adding a disc to complete a collection
A completionist may want all the work of a particular artist
Collecting DVDs, Blu-rays, and 4K discs isn’t that different from collecting your favorite artist’s music. If you have a favorite band or artist, back in the days when CDs were the main listening format for music enthusiasts, you might have instantly bought anything they released.
If you were a particularly dedicated fan, you may have also purchased hard-to-find releases, imports, bootlegs, and anything else that can help you complete your collection.
It’s possible you may not have gotten around to listening to every single CD you bought from that artist. However, as a fan, it may have been important to you to support said artist by completing your collection of their work. Building this type of collection can also help you establish the way being a fan of an artist informs your overall identity.
The same principle can apply to DVDs, Blu-rays, and 4K discs. If there is a director or actor whose work you love, you might want to own all their movies, even if some of those movies are the type which you’re not actually all that motivated to watch.
DVDS, Blu-rays and 4K discs may look impressive on display
Again, there are many reasons physical media fans prefer to buy discs rather than watching titles via streaming services or digital platforms. One of those reasons is that the packaging of these discs, particularly if they’re released via boutique labels like the Criterion Collection, may be works of art themselves. Maybe there’s a particularly special edition of a title whose packaging seems to complement other titles in your collection.
For example, as a fan of both live music and Criterion discs, I’ve bought many concert films and music documentaries from the Criterion Collection. Some of these include concert films that I haven’t watched yet, and am not necessarily all that eager to watch anytime soon.
Regardless, the way their cover and sleeve artwork works with the art of the other discs that I own creates an overall aesthetic effect that adds to the tangible artistic value of my collection.
That’s just one example. Generally, it’s worth remembering that physical media can be displayed as art in your home. Thus, you may be inclined to sometimes buy physical media you’ve yet to actually consume.
Sometimes a disc can gain value over time
It’s important to understand that a physical media collection usually isn’t the type of financial investment that will pay major dividends down the line. That said, there are exceptions.
Every now and then, a particularly rare release appreciates in value over the years. This may happen if a boutique label or studio releases a rare special edition, if signed editions are released, or if a studio is going to decide to stop producing copies of a certain disc.
In these cases, sometimes a disc’s value will increase to the point that it can provide a seller with a nice payday.
This is one of the more practical reasons to buy physical copies of movies you’ve never seen. You just need to do thorough research to ensure what you think might be a quality investment will actually turn out to be that.
Again, none of this is to suggest that the average consumer will have much reason to start buying up discs of movies they don’t plan on watching. However, for a certain breed of physical media enthusiast, this practice can make some sense. These are just some of the reasons why.

